Is it enough to stem the tide? 

While Humza Yousaf tried to use yesterday’s Programme for Government to reset his leadership, Scotland’s opposition parties tried to use it to stake out new lines of attack on his administration. First among their areas of focus is economic growth, which both the Scottish Conservatives and Scottish Labour believe is a significant blackspot on the SNP government’s record.

This strategy was revealed even before the Programme for Government was announced. Just last week the Scottish Conservative Party leader Douglas Ross launched a well-received plan for growth. Only days later Scottish Labour Party leader Anas Sarwar followed suit, announcing a new expert advisory panel to inform his economic policy, as well as – crucially — a presumption against further income tax rises. As both Ross and Sarwar set out their pro-growth stalls, they also highlighted research for True North by Survation, which suggested people in Scotland no longer feel they get value for money from public services, despite the highest income tax burden in the UK.

While such a move may be expected from the Scottish Conservative Party – indeed, reducing income tax in Scotland has been their long-standing position – it is a significant change for the Scottish Labour Party.

Sarwar is attempting to outflank the SNP from the centre by winning over middle-class Scots currently disgruntled at the state of public services and perhaps more conscious of tax bills due to cost-of-living pressures. Of course, there is little detail yet on what, if anything, Scottish Labour would sacrifice to keep tax bills down, but one of the luxuries of opposition is being able to avoid such awkward decisions.

But while a significant change, Scottish Labour’s stance should not come as a great surprise. Not only is it good politics to oppose further tax rises, it also fits with the UK party’s wider direction. As Sir Keir Starmer’s latest reshuffle at Westminster showed, the political heirs of Tony Blair are once again in the ascendency. It is therefore thoroughly in keeping that the Scottish party is slowly reverting to an unapologetically pro-growth, pro-business agenda once again as well.

Andrew Liddle

Andrew Liddle

Senior Advisor

Keep in touch

Sign up to our newsletter.

"*" indicates required fields

Insights & news

Fergus Mutch in Aberdeen
Something worth voting for? 
On Thursday, health secretary Michael Matheson resigned and Humza Yousaf undertook a ‘mini-reshuffle’ of his cabinet. The scandal of the £11,000 iPad bill was only ever going to end this way. That it was allowed to rumble on eroding public trust for months is symptomatic of the SNP’s wider fortunes, which began to rapidly deteriorate almost a year ago to this day. Fifty-one weeks ago a press conference was hastily arranged in the Drawing Room at Bute House. Nicola Sturgeon stood before Alexander Nasmyth’s pastoral portrait of Robert Burns, announced her resignation as first minister and set in motion a remarkable chain of events...
Read more
  • Insight & Analytics
  • Political Analysis
  • SNP
Happy New Year for Keir?
anuary is hardly the optimal season for camping in Scotland, but with a General Election looming it was only to be expected that the New Year bells would be accompanied by a flurry of political tent pitching. Rishi Sunak’s beleaguered government is rapidly running out of time to turn things around, but despite Labour’s sustained and substantial lead in the polls, the Tories have not yet thrown in the towel. Although the Prime Minister has indicated a preference for an election in the second half of the year, he could well be bluffing. He’s certainly keeping his options open. Astute observers will have noticed that the date of the Spring Budget 2024 has been brought forward to 6 March, when the Chancellor is widely expected to hand out sweeties for everyone...
Read more
  • Insight & Analytics
  • Political Analysis
Geoff and Panel
The morning after the budget before
The latest Scottish Government budget was the most significant of the devolution era. In her first public event since she announced her tax and spend plans yesterday, speaking at a True North business breakfast in Edinburgh Finance Secretary Shona Robison defended her decision to significantly raise personal taxation, saying she had to make “wicked decisions and choices” to protect spending on key public services such as the NHS. Among the headline budget announcements was the creation of a new 45 percent tax band on incomes between £75,000 and £125,140, while the top rate of tax was also raised to 48 percent. Meanwhile, the higher..
Read more
  • Events
  • Insight & Analytics
  • SNP
  • Tax